The Labour Section of the Naples Court of Appeal rejected ASL Napoli 1 Centro's appeal and upheld the order to supply Christian Durso with the complete prescribed verticalizing electric wheelchair, according to ANSA.
The court held that authorizing a fixed sum is not enough unless the health authority shows that the sum can buy a device with the technical and functional characteristics the person requires. According to ANSA, the ASL had not identified a concretely suitable alternative and had relied on objections the court considered generic.
The dispute followed the ASL's partial authorization of a specialist-prescribed wheelchair because the requested model exceeded tariff nomenclature limits. The case developed through successive proceedings after Durso's previous wheelchair became obsolete, was no longer produced and could not be repaired because replacement parts were unavailable, according to ANSA.
The judicial reasoning emphasizes individualized assessment of clinical needs, residual abilities, living environment and the level of autonomy to be guaranteed. The Association Luca Coscioni described the appellate decision as relevant beyond the individual case and potentially significant for other disputes over prosthetic assistance.



