The Council of State has rejected two appeals by the Municipality of Ischia against Maria Giovanna Villari and Carlo Villari over ownership of the Pineta Villari complex, according to Il Golfo 24.

In decision No. 8140, the court rejected the municipality's position that prolonged possession had automatically transferred ownership through usucapion.

The dispute concerns land used for more than 40 years as a public park and for related infrastructure without a completed valid transfer of ownership.

The municipality's proposed route is acquisition under Article 42-bis of Italy's Consolidated Expropriation Act, covering the Pineta Villari complex identified by cadastral sheet 8, parcels 1392 and 3290.

The procedure follows earlier TAR Campania decisions No. 1436/2022 and No. 1065/2025.

The Council of State also rejected the argument that the owners' compensation claims were automatically time-barred, treating occupation without valid title as a continuing unlawful situation until restitution or lawful acquisition.

Ischia's municipal council has approved extending the sanatoria acquisition procedure to the entire property complex, according to Teleischia. Teleischia reports the council vote followed a preliminary refusal by the Ministry of Culture.

The Villari heirs had requested in a filing dated 30 July 2021 either restoration and damages or formal acquisition with the legally due compensation.

The amount of compensation remains to be decided elsewhere: the TAR could not determine the amount, and disputes over the amount belong to the ordinary courts, particularly the Court of Appeal.