The Tribunal of Napoli, Ischia section, rejected in full a payment claim of €43,799.55 brought by Ecogea srl against the Comune di Forio, according to Il Golfo 24.
The dispute concerned the rental of two hydraulic presses used to compact paper and cardboard. The original contract was signed in July 2011, provided for a monthly fee of €1,200 plus VAT, and had an initial term of two years, according to Ischia7.
Ecogea argued that the relationship had continued through automatic renewals until 2024 and claimed payment after municipal payments allegedly stopped in June 2023. The court did not accept that reconstruction.
The court accepted the Comune di Forio’s argument that the rental of movable equipment falls under public procurement rules for supplies and cannot be extended through tacit renewal without a new award procedure and the required administrative acts. The alternative claim based on unjust enrichment was also rejected.
The reports identify Maria Pia De Riso as the judge and Giuseppe Carnevale as counsel for the Comune di Forio.
On costs, Ecogea was ordered to pay €4,606 in legal costs, while Vincenzo Rando was ordered to reimburse an additional €2,304, for a reported total of €6,910 before statutory accessories.



